History Day award winner -- Bainbridge Island: A Close-Knit Community's Tragedy and Triumph by Jack Hanley

  • By Jack Hanley
  • Posted 6/21/2007
  • HistoryLink.org Essay 9962

Jack Hanley, a Junior at Seattle Prep, won first place in the Senior Division of the 2007 History Day competition with this essay on Bainbridge Island's Japanese American internment.

A Community's Tragedy and Triumph

At the onset of World War II, over 122,000 Japanese Americans living in the Western United States were forced to leave their homes by order of the government. Almost all were sent to internment camps in remote locations away from the West Coast. For many of them local community pressure, fueled by war hysteria and racism, drove them out of their neighborhoods (Kashima 175). The experience of the Japanese-Americans on Bainbridge Island, Washington, was quite different. Japanese Americans were an integral part of the fabric of this island community; for that reason, their expulsion was more painful than elsewhere, but those community ties also greatly helped in their triumphant return at the end of the war.

The Japanese American community thrived on Bainbridge Island, living in harmony with other races until the Pearl Harbor attack (Visible Target). At the end of the nineteeth century, Bainbridge Island's Port Blakely mill, the largest in Washington, drew laborers from several countries including Japan. In 1890, the mill employed 200 Scandinavians, 50 Americans, and 24 Japanese (Swain 3). The Japanese mill workers eventually gravitated to agriculture. They had arrived with farming skills and an intense work ethic. No competition existed for this kind of difficult work, and the Japanese provided produce which the white population valued.

Wealthy Seattle families with summer homes on sparsely populated rural Bainbridge Island did not oppose settlement by the Issei, first generation Japanese Americans (Swain 3-7, 14). Despite their contributions and acceptance, the Issei faced barriers, including the 1921 Alien Land Law which forbade land ownership by non­citizens (Niiya). Japanese aliens found ways to sidestep the law by leasing property and eventually purchasing land in the names of their children (Nisei), who were American citizens. By 1940, there were 54 Japanese-ancestry families located on the Island, and they had become an integral, important part of the Bainbridge community (Swain 9, 19).

The shocking attack of Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, threw the U.S. into a state of war against Japan. The next morning, publishers Walt and Millie Woodward released a special "War Extra" issue of their newspaper, the Bainbridge Review. In it they reassured their fellow islanders that the 300 Japanese Americans living on Bainbridge were completely loyal to the United States (Woodward, "War Extra"). They urged the community to look past the ancestry of their Japanese neighbors and to continue to accept them as loyal Americans.

"These Japanese-Americans of ours haven't bombed anybody. In the past, they have given every indication of loyalty to this nation ... Let us so live in this trying time that when it is all over loyal Americans can look loyal Americans in the eye with the knowledge that, together,
they kept the Stars and Stripes flying high over the land of
the brave and the home of the free" (Woodward: War Extra).

Woodward was the only editor of a newspaper in Western Washington to loudly and repeatedly stand up for the local Japanese and Japanese American residents (Hannula).

Fear of anything Japanese soon spread throughout the country. On February 19, 1942, President Roosevelt issued Executive Order No. 9066, which gave local military authorities the power to do whatever was necessary to protect the nation from the Japanese enemy (Roosevelt). As one historian wrote, "The belief that Japanese American citizens were untrustworthy and likely to engage in spying and sabotage was considered almost conventional wisdom" (Neiwert 123). Soon this led to the forced removal from their homes of all Japanese and Japanese Americans living along the West Coast. Bainbridge Island was the first to suffer (Niiya).

On March 24, 1942, military authorities issued Civilian Exclusion Order No. 1, requiring the removal of all Japanese and Japanese Americans from Bainbridge Island. Both Issei and Nisei were given only six days to prepare for the move (Ohtaki). This was a complete disruption of all aspects of life. The Island Japanese had to make arrangements regarding their property, complete their goodbyes, and evaluate what possessions they would take with them, as they were allowed to take only what they could physically carry (Visible Target). Their Island neighbors helped them as best they could by agreeing to care for their farms and protect their homes.

This was in sharp contrast to other communities, such as Bellevue, Washington; when a relocation order was issued for that area, the white neighbors chose to take advantage of the situation. There were many instances of whites buying household goods for unfair prices from the evicted Japanese and taking possession of farmland with no intention of sharing the resulting profits (Neiwert 134-138). Mitsi Shiraishi, a Japanese woman from Bellevue, recalled, "People came to buy things for nothing. And they would offer you a measly five dollars or something for something that we could still use" (Neiwert 138).

When news of Exclusion Order No. 1 hit Bainbridge, Woodward became furious and began a series of newspaper articles defending the Islanders and criticizing the forced removal. He also argued that such a violation of constitutional rights could be directed at anyone (Holt). Woodward said, "The Review has stuck its neck out good and proper for you people not because you are [you people] but because you are Americans and temporarily have lost the citizenship rights this nation guarantees to every citizen" (Ohtaki). This reaction to the removal of the Japanese was vastly different from the media's actions in other parts of the West Coast. In San Francisco, the media created hatred toward the Japanese. Kazuo Ishimitsu remembered the newspapers:

"Well, if you read the Hearst papers or any of those, or listen to the radio programs, you know that they created hate....And because of that, they tell you you're 'slant-eyes' and all that, it was so predominant, 'yellow-belly,' that kind, it does affect the young mind" (Pak 130).

This hatred seeped into the surrounding communities. Japanese American students in schools noticed changes in the attitudes of their fellow white students. Some Chinese even began wearing buttons saying, "I am Chinese," in order not to be associated with the Japanese. Other students were abused by former friends who allowed the propaganda to influence their opinions of the Japanese (Pak 130-134).

On March 30, 1942, at 11:00 a.m. the Island Japanese Americans boarded a ferry to Seattle. From Seattle, they rode a train to central California (UW article). On that day, many Island people showed their support by heading to the ferry dock and saying their final goodbyes. Students at Bainbridge High left their classes, and adults took the day off to watch as their companions boarded the ship without protest or resistance. This day still represents the saddest day of many persons' lives.

"We said goodbye, With a great deal of worry. Everyone cried and apologized, And said 'We're so sorry!' They did come back, After years of strife, Now 54 years later I recall, The saddest day of my life" (Ritchie).


By contrast, in the following months Japanese Americans were uprooted from other communities in Washington without public acknowledgment from their neighbors, who were either indifferent or glad to see them go (Neiwert 140-141).

Once the Bainbridge Islanders reached their first internment camp in faraway Manzanar, California, they did not show anger or malice to the authorities or government; they wished to show continuing loyalty by being extremely obedient and compliant. In Manzanar, the Islanders found themselves to be the outsiders. Of the 10,000 internees, the Islanders made up about 275 of them. (Another 25 Islanders had voluntarily left the West Coast before Order No. 1 was issued.) Walt Woodward criticized the choice of Manzanar for them.

"That is like putting one Washington apple in a crate of California lemons. The Review has a pitiful file of letters – as do many Islanders – from our evacuated residents, telling how utterly foreign they have found some of their California 'neighbors' to be"(Woodward: Apples and Lemons).

The Islanders noticed that, while they had the same ancestry as the Californian internees, and looked the same, they were quite different. They felt extremely isolated and did not mix well with the Californian Japanese. During a riot at the camp, the Bainbridge Island Japanese displayed their loyalty by not participating. They hoped that they would be relocated to another camp where they would fit in better. The Islanders were unique in their unwavering obedience to the camp authorities (Woodward: Apples and Lemons).

Woodward used the Bainbridge Review as a unique channel of communication for the internees. He created an "Open Forum" column in his newspaper and published articles from Japanese internment camp correspondents. These articles humanized the Japanese's situation by reporting births, deaths, graduations, marriages, Army enlistments, and the location of those Islanders who were allowed to work or attend school outside the camp. This allowed Island readers to follow the misfortunes of their former neighbors. The Island readers responded by expressing their support for Woodward's activities. "I would like to take this opportunity to congratulate you on your front-page editorial in last week's Review on the Japanese evacuation problem. It was excellent and, I believe, well expressed the attitude of the majority of Islanders" (Halvorsen).

Woodward made sure his newspaper was also a channel of communication to the internees. He sent copies of the Review to the camp each week. In this fashion the internees were able to keep informed about events and activities in their former community such as sports, the activities of churches and clubs, and election results. This helped the internees remain mentally connected to Bainbridge Island (Ohtaki). Paul Ohtaki said it best: "Walt Woodward wanted us to feel like we had a home to come back to" (Visible Target).

World War II ended on September 2, 1945, with the unconditional surrender of the Empire of Japan (Kashima 221). After three and half years of internment, the Japanese Americans from Bainbridge Island wanted to return home, but they were uncertain what the future held. Woodward used the Bainbridge Review to promote the idea of return.

Even in the close-knit community, there was some public resistance. Lambert Schuyler was the leading advocate for the continuing exclusion of the Japanese. He was an open racist and tried to stir up the community to oppose the return of the Japanese. He verbally attacked anyone who was in favor of the Japanese's return and passionately argued for their exclusion from the Island:

"Whether Nisei or not, whether loyal or not, Japs who return to Bainbridge will be met by insult and abuse, if not worse ... The Jap is not assimilable ... Unless we are prepared to love and intermarry with the Japs we may expect more Nisei to be traitors at heart ... . We don't want any Japs back here ever" (Schuyler).

A meeting was held on the Island on November 3, 1944, called by Schuyler to stir up opposition to any return of the Japanese to Bainbridge. About 200 people attended. It was later recognized that the reason for such a high number was mere curiosity. For example, even Millie Woodward, Walt's wife, attended the meeting to see what was going on. At the next meeting called by the agitators, on November 24, 1944, only 34 persons attended, including many children (Swain 124-126 ). In fact, by the time the internees arrived, there was no visible opposition to the Japanese American Islanders' return and they were welcomed.

The return of the Bainbridge Island Japanese was facilitated by a public welcome from their former friends, neighbors, and business associates. "When the interned Japanese Americans returned to Bainbridge, 'there wasn't one damned incident, Woodward recalls. He claims no credit, but others know that his treatment of the tragedy of internment was largely responsible" (Hannula).

The internees did not come back as strangers. When Gerry Nakata returned, "one of his closest white friends from high school met him at the ferry dock to welcome him home. Back on the Island, Nakata felt no animosity and he and his brother resumed their family's grocery business" (Swain 154). They partnered with the Loveriches to open a grocery, butcher, and florist operation. Myrtle Norman had looked after her longtime friend Shigako Kitamoto's home and property. Felix Narta had managed Shigako Kitamoto's strawberry farms and turned them back to her; she rewarded him with a piece of property on which to build a home. Bainbridge Gardens Greenhouse & Store, which had been a showcase, was ruined from neglect and theft during the war, but the two Japanese owners' families divided the property and began life anew on the Island. Over one-half of the Japanese-American families who had been exiled from Bainbridge Island returned to the island after the war (Moriwaki 4). They were reintegrated into the community and reclaimed their rightful places in society (Visible Target).

The experiences in other Washington communities were not so triumphant. For example, in Bellevue, agitators called a meeting to express opposition to the return of their former Japanese American neighbors, and over 500 persons attended. The local business interests did not want to see the Japanese return their fields to strawberry production, hoping to purchase and redevelop the lands as office parks and residential suburbs for their own profit. The Issei and Nisei who had been exiled from Bellevue did not have a local champion like Woodward, and had fewer and weaker bonds to their former neighborhood. Consequently, out of the 60 Japanese American families in Bellevue at the time of their removal, only 11 returned after the War (Neiwert 214).

Through perseverance and courage, the Bainbridge Island Japanese were able to recover more quickly and completely from the tragedy of internment after the war. In a country filled with people of all nationalities, a melting pot, the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor caused an unjustified suspension of constitutional rights. The tragedy of uprooting legal aliens and U.S. citizens of Japanese descent without legal warrants, hearings, or court orders demonstrates the vulnerability of freedom in America in time of war. The loss of economic livelihood and prosperity suffered by these victims was not compensated in any significant way. (In 1988, finally, Congress passed a law, signed by President Reagan, requiring the federal government to send, to each surviving internee, a letter of apology and a payment of $20,000.)

The government's ability to turn a blind eye toward human rights when they conflict with the goal of national defense is an important lesson for today. The United States government is waging a "War on Terror" against Muslim extremists. Even today, the government can abuse the rights of Muslim Americans for national security. As in 1941, a vocal press is needed to protect those rights.

Relocation was a tragic injustice. Individual human determination and neighborly compassion helped the Islanders heal the wounds of this injustice, maintain their ties to this community even while exiled, and regain their standing on Bainbridge Island after the war ended. Other Japanese American communities were not as blessed, and some never recovered from the effects of exile. One should never forget the lesson of this tragedy, that even the United States government is capable of abusing basic citizen rights in the name of security (Rehnquist 3-8). One should also remember the lesson of the triumph achieved by Bainbridge Island, which is that individual courage and a strong sense of community loyalty can overcome such abuse.


Sources:

Note: What follows is Jack Hanley's annoated bibliography of "Works Cited."

Primary Sources

Halvorsen, Mrs. Luke. Bainbridge Review. 2 Apr. 1942: Open Forum, pg 4, Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

In this letter to the Editor, Mrs. Luke Halvorsen states her appreciation for Walt Woodward and his attempts to defend the Japanese and keep a close connection. She believes he is accurately expressing the thought of most Islanders. This was helpful because it provided and example of how people responded to Woodward and his work.

Hayashi, Masumi. "American Concentration Camps: Map." Cleveland State University, 14 January 2007.

Map of the Relocation Camps showing the relative location of the some camps mentioned or analyzed.

Kashima, Tetsuden. Judgment Without Trial. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2003.

Tetsuden Kashima shares his story of internment along with his own opinions about the U.S. government and its plans for the Japanese-American population. He uses past documents to prove his points.

Ohtaki, Paul T. It Was The Right Thing To Do. 7 Dec. 2001.

Ohtaki has put together a book full of historical newspapers, letters, and other useful pieces of literature. This book is only found on at the Bainbridge Island Historical Society and Museum. It is everything that I could ever need in terms of primary documents. It was helpful in not only giving me vast amount of information, but also in giving me a sense of the feelings of the Japanese and the whites. Ohtaki worked for the Woodwards at the Bainbridge Review and once he was interned, he was the first correspondent to allow that close-knit community to remain. Ohtaki does not share his own thoughts; however the majority of the pieces of literature within the book have bias.

Ritchie, Gena. "The Saddest Day of My Life." Apr. 1942. Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Gena Ritchie wrote this poem right after the removal of the Japanese on Bainbridge Island. Ritchie was a high school student at the time and was a friend of many Japanese-Americans who were forced to leave. She expresses her emotions and what went on during the day the Japanese were evacuated. She uses rhyming to bring a little light on the darkest and saddest day of her life. This is helpful in that it shows how integrated the Japanese were in the community. It is difficult to acknowledge that there might be bias because she is sharing her feelings, however she was a friend to many and that may have influence her writing.

Secondary Sources

Roosevelt, Franklin D. "Executive Order No. 9066." 19 Feb. 1942. Seattle Prep Library. 2 Oct. 2006, .

This allows me to see the actual Order and see what was written by President Roosevelt. This was helpful because I could view the actual document.

Schuyler, Lambert. The Live and Let Live Legion: We Live in Our Country-Let the Japs Live in Theirs. 24 Jan. 1945: 3 (1/6p.), Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Lambert Schuyler was one of the few open racists on the Island. He openly opposed the return of the Japanese-Americans to Bainbridge and even sent out this source (Bulletin) to many members of the community. In his Bulletin he insults those who defend the Japanese and makes absurd comments about them. There is most definitely bias in his Bulletin, as many Islanders soon realized. This is helpful because it gives me the mindset of the few who supported the internment and opposed the return of the Japanese.

Woodward, Walt. "War Extra: Island Defense Set!" Bainbridge Review. 8 Dec. 1941, pg 2, Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Walt Woodward published this War Extra following the attack on Pearl Harbor. In this Extra, Woodward defends the Bainbridge Island Japanese and addresses the fact that they are loyal to the U.S. This article was helpful in providing me with an immediate response to the attack on Pearl Harbor.

Woodward, Walt. "You Shouldn't Pack Apples with Lemons." Bainbridge Review. 17 Dec. 1942, pg 3, Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Walt Woodward discusses the relationship between Bainbridge Island Japanese-Americans and Japanese-Americans from other parts of the Pacific Coast. He calls the Bainbridge Islanders Americans and the other Japanese aliens. He tries to convince the reader that it is wrong to put too extremely different types of people cramped together. While they may look the same, the Bainbridge Islanders are more "American." The two peoples are extremely different from on another and he calls for the relocation of the Bainbridge Island Japanese-Americans. This article is helpful in that it shows how different Bainbridge Japanese were different from others and that difference along with being more "American", helped in their return to Bainbridge. Woodward most-likely has bias because he was a great friend to many Japanese-Americans from Bainbridge and wishes to defend them and say they are more "American".

This article gave a brief description of the overall internment and process taken by the U.S government. It also describes the preparations made by the Japanese on Bainbridge. It was helpful in finding specific information such as facts.

Hannula, Don. "The lonely voice against internment." Seattle Times 14 Sept. 1981: A14, Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Don Hannula wrote this article to express the Woodwards' brave and unique actions during the time of hysteria. He discusses how the Woodwards fought for the Japanese-Americans, how he fought for their citizenship. This is another source that gives me information on the Woodwards and their tremendous courage.

Holt, Gordy. "How Woodwards fought a war." Seattle Post-Intelligencer 15 Mar. 2001, sec. B:6, Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Gordy Holt gives a brief but accurate description of the Woodwards efforts to openly dismiss Japanese internment. It focuses on "How Woodwards fought a war." It acknowledges his beneficial actions to limit the breaking up of the Bainbridge community. The Woodwards, Walt and Millie, were the only editors who openly expressed their discontent of the situation. They were instrumental in the return and triumph of the Japanese re-establishing themselves in the community. I do not believe there is much bias present by Gordy Holt, however current people involved in the media may enjoy praising past members of the media to show their importance.

Moriwaki, Clarence. "The Memorial, Phase One." BIJAC News. Winter 2005-6: 3 (1/5p.). Bainbridge Island Historical Society & Museum.

Clarence Moriwaki describes the process of building the Nidoto Nai Yoni-Let It Not Happen Again memorial. He also describes the importance this memorial will have on the Japanese Community and the Island as a whole. He mentions how deep the wounds of internment are and shares some people's feelings and the significance. This gives me a sense of how large the internment was a part of the community.

Neiwert, David A. Strawberry Days: How Internment Destroyed A Japanese American Community. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005.

David A. Neiwert tells the story of Japanese-Americans in Bellevue, who created a community, and then saw their farms and families torn apart by the removal of Japanese-Americans. Neiwert uses personal histories along with other resources to explain this tragedy. This was helpful to my paper because it give another community, Bellevue, to compare to Bainbridge. The two were totally different in their connections with whites and their returns to those different communities. The reactions of the whites are also evident, so I will be able to compare those as well.

Niiya, Brian. "A Short Chronology of Japanese American History." Japanese American History: An A-to-Z Reference from 1868 to the Present. 1993. New York: Facts­on-File. 19 Oct. 2006 < http://www.janet.org/janet_history/niiya_chron.html>.

This Chronology gave me a brief sense of what the history of the Japanese people in America was. It varied from different subjects; from migrants to discrimination. It was helpful in getting a better understanding of the context.

Pak, Yoon K. Wherever I Go, I Will Always Be a Loyal American. New York: RoutledgeFalmer, 2002.

Yoon K. Pak documents different students' struggles, at different schools, with the Japanese internment and racism. She includes many primary documents, letters, from students to various people. This source was helpful is humanizing the abuse the Japanese received and how they just wanted to fit in.

Rehnquist, William H. "When the Laws were Silent." American Heritage Vol. 49, n.6 (Oct 1998): 76 (1/12p.). Seattle Prep Library. 19 Oct. 2006

< http://galenet.galegroup.com>.

Chief Justice Rehnquist explains the legal justification for Executive Order 9066, which ordered the relocation and internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II. In his opinion, "laws will thus not be silent in time of war, even though they will speak with a somewhat different voice." This article is helpful because it gives me another perspective of the internment.

Swain, Alison M. THEIR OWN ISLAND: The Japanese American community on Bainbridge Island, Washington, 1890-1945. Williamstown: Williams College, 2001.

Alison Swain compares the experience of internment and relocation of Bainbridge Island Japanese-Americans to that of the Hood River Valley, Oregon. She not only compares the internment and relocation, but also the return and different stereo-types of each community. I feel this book will be very helpful because it is one of the few books directly focused on Bainbridge Island.

Visible Target. Videotape. Wombat Film & Video, 1986.

This video examines the lives of those who were relocated. It uses interviews, old newsreel clips, comic strips, anti-Japanese propaganda to show the prejudice and hatred toward the Japanese. It contains many primary sources within. This video was helpful in allowing me to see the reactions of the Japanese and the effects this injustice had on their lives'.


Related Topics:   Asian & Pacific Islander Americans | War & Peace

Licensing: This essay is licensed under a Creative Commons license that encourages reproduction with attribution. Credit should be given to both HistoryLink.org and to the author, and sources must be included with any reproduction. Click the icon for more info. Please note that this Creative Commons license applies to text only, and not to images. For more information regarding individual photos or images, please contact the source noted in the image credit.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License
Major Support for HistoryLink.org Provided By: The State of Washington | Patsy Bullitt Collins | Paul G. Allen Family Foundation | Museum Of History & Industry | 4Culture (King County Lodging Tax Revenue) | City of Seattle | City of Bellevue | City of Tacoma | King County | The Peach Foundation | Microsoft Corporation, Other Public and Private Sponsors and Visitors Like You