The building was altered over the years. Its wooden shingle exterior was replaced with asphalt shakes. In 1931, one entrance was removed during modifications.
In 1966, the congregation merged with Olivet Congregational Church and sold the structure to the Mars Hill Baptist Church. It later became home to the Beacon Hill First Baptist Church.
The Seattle City Council designated the church a Seattle Landmark on December 28, 1981, because it represented an outstanding example of Storey's work and because of its distinctive architectural style.